Today, I got to play a small part in the conferencing of a few of our denominational leaders in the area of church development. By invitation of my conference’s director, Tommy Willingham, I spoke for a little less than 15 minutes about the highs and lows of church planting. I was joined with Teresa Angle-Young and Rodrigo Cruz. When it was my turn to present, I shared a quick intro about The Vine. To celebrate the highs of church planting, I showed them our church’s Year 2 Recap. I DID NOT SHOW THEM THIS VIDEO. I’m still not really sure why we made that series of commercials. Anyway, when I was done celebrated the good, I candidly shared with them the bad. Here’s a list of the bad (very general to protect the identities of folks):
1. When partnering with an existing ministry to begin a new ministry, there needs to be an agreed upon vision. One of our struggles as a new church was differing visions. Before the partnership, semantically, everyone was on the same page. However, once plans developed it was clear that there were two different visions. If you’re a leader responsible for these partnerships or any other partnerships, it’s your responsibility to make sure the visions align. Furthermore, when two people or ministries merge, both parties should be equally trained and evaluated.
2. Planting a church is an inadequate metaphor for starting a church. I think a better descriptor is birthing a church. Why? Well, I can plant a tree in my backyard with relative ease and minimal mess. I cannot, however, say the same about birthing a church. It’s more involved than one person. It’s messy and frankly, sometimes it stinks. Well, when you birth a church, there’s a difference between pre-delivery and post-delivery. As a church birther, I experience post-partum something. I wouldn’t call it depression, but there was definitely a funk! I think it came from reality setting it. Church birthers hear the glorious start of Rob Bell and think that it will be replicated in their setting. I can, but it probably won’t. Week 2 is possibly more disappointing than week 1. So, if you’re a birther please know that pre-launch is ideal world. Post-launch is real world! If you’re a coach, teach your birthers that reality. Encourage them in that reality.
3. One of the most difficult aspects of birthing a church is institutional opposition. I was warned of this by our boot camp coach. I didn’t believe that would happen b/c I’m generally naive and non-competitive with other church. Plus, there’s this “connection” our church was apart of called the denomination. Yet, when we arrived in our context to start, there was opposition. So, here’s my suggestion: If you’re responsible for making the call to send out a pastor into a community that has any other existing churches, you’re called to be the forerunner, bridge-builder, and John the Baptist paving the way for that Church Birther. The Kingdom needs MOST churches and even if there were another 1,000 church in any community, it wouldn’t reach all the unchurched, pre-Christian folks. Furthermore, if the birthed church is doing it’s job, it’s not going “steal” church members (it’s actually absurd b/c you can’t steal people in America…that’s illegal)! Furthermore, if there is opposition from the institution, don’t contact the church birther the night before they launch.
4. One of the greatest struggles of church birthing and leading any church is comparing yourself to others. People matter to God, but size doesn’t! There, I said it! The pastor has a hard enough time comparing himself/herself with others, that he/she doesn’t need any other person adding to that struggle. In the early days, when I’d celebrate the number of people I had a person in my life who’d almost immediately say, “Did you hear about ________ and how many people he had?” Nope, but I guess you’re going to tell me and make me feel inferior. So, bottom line: Don’t compare yourself to others. Don’t compare others to a church birthers. It’s unfair! Instead, celebrate each person God brings your way as one individual entrusted to your care. If you’re not the birther, encourage him/her in what God did in that church rather than what God didn’t do or rather than compare him or her to someone else. Each birther is uniquely made and wired!
There are more lows, but that’s all I shared today. Maybe more to come!
Need to confess?